DNA Genotek's Sample Collection Blog

Can saliva replace blood for DNA collection and analysis? (Part 3 of 3)

Posted by Kerry Chatburn on Wed, Jul 25, 2012 @ 11:07 AM

DNA saliva and blood costWelcome to the final article in our 3 part series discussing whether or not saliva can replace blood for DNA collection and analysis. In part 1 and part 2 of this blog series, we examined the quality and functionality/ease of use of blood and saliva. In this final part, we look at the cost of both types of DNA samples. We hope you find this content interesting. Let us know what you think of this series by leaving a comment. Thank you in advance.

The price associated with blood collection may be perceived to be free for many institutions that have established blood collection labs/service centers; however, there are real costs to sample collection even within these environments. Phlebotomists, lab technicians, medical supplies, and shipping requirements (dry ice, containers, and overnight delivery) add to an estimated $40 per sample, not including freezer storage1. Oragene, in comparison, comes in a variety of formats with differing yield and stability capabilities which cost between 48% - 80% less. More savings are introduced as Oragene products enable at-home collection, standard shipping via regular mail at room temperature and zero refrigeration.

Daksis, J.I. et al. states, “The acquisition of high quality DNA for molecular assay from oral samples offers clear advantages in cost, handling, storing and shipping over acquisition of samples from blood. … It therefore opens the way for convenient point of care testing…”2

Basham, R.J. et al. claims “…saliva [Oragene.DNA]… allows cost-efficient storage and shipping. In contrast, whole blood must either be extracted within a few days, or stored at −70°C until extracted.”3

Abraham J.E et al. continues “… commercial extraction of DNA from saliva is cheaper than from blood.”4

And another study by Nishiya, D.M. et al. reports “Obtaining blood biospecimens presents logistical and financial challenges. As a result, saliva biospecimen collection is becoming more frequent because of the ease of collection and lower cost.” 5

That being said, many clinicians and labs benefit from their institution’s internal procurement established for blood collection and are therefore exposed to minimal, if any, costs. But when working with children, psychiatric patients, or remote donors a blood sample is less convenient and more time consuming when a practical alternative exists.

I close with Abraham, J.E et al. “… [Oragene.DNA kits] are more expensive than blood sampling kits however this cost has to be counter-balanced by the increased inconvenience to the patient and the cost of trained staff required to obtain blood samples.” 4

In conclusion, can saliva replace blood for DNA collection and analysis? Yes, and in fact it has started to already. Oragene is currently used as an alternative when blood is not a viable option in 250 hospitals worldwide, including 9 of the top 10 hospitals in the United States. Saliva is increasingly becoming an equally important standard practice in healthcare for DNA based sample collection, especially for children, patients with mental health disabilities, and those who cannot efficiently access a blood clinic.

With that, we are closing this series on whether saliva can replace blood for DNA collection and analysis. Be sure to subscribe to our blog so you can be notified of other content like this.

References

1 Ambrosone C.B. et al. Conducting Molecular Epidemiological Research in the Age of HIPAA: A Multi-Institutional Case-Control Study of Breast Cancer in African-American and European-American Women. J Oncol. 2009: 1-15 (2009).

2 CRN: Specimen Collection within the CRN: A critical appraisal.

3 Daksis J.I. and Erikson G.H. Heteropolymeric Triplex-Based Genomic Assay® to Detect Pathogens or Single-Nucleotide Polymorphisms in Human Genomic Samples. PLoS ONE. 2(3): e305 (2007).

Abraham, J.E. et al. (2012). Saliva samples are a viable alternative to blood samples as a source of DNA for high throughput genotyping.

5 Nishita D.M. et al. Clinical trial participant characteristics and saliva and DNA metrics. BMC Med Res Method. 9(71): 1-20 (2009).

Tags: DNA collection, DNA saliva, DNA saliva cost, blood DNA cost

Subscribe to our blog

Request free trial kits of any DNA Genotek product.

Request free trial kits

Disclaimers

This blog is intended to provide information to educate readers about molecular testing and genetic sample collection and DNA Genotek products.  Some of the information on this blog represents emerging scientific research or data developed for research purposes only. More information here.

Follow us

About DNA Genotek

Welcome to The Genetic Link, a blog providing new insights into DNA and RNA sample collection by DNA Genotek. DNA Genotek is a subsidiary of OraSure Technologies, Inc.

Most Popular Posts

Browse by Tag